Payday loan vs cash advance app vs pawn loan vs asking for more time
Same $300, same two weeks. The cost ranges from $0 to $75, and the downside ranges from a phone call to a lawsuit. The cheapest option is usually the one people try last.
Swipe or scroll to compare all options
Payday loan Storefront or online, due on your next payday | Cash advance app Earnin, Dave, Brigit, Chime SpotMe, etc. | Pawn loan Cash against an item you leave with the shop | Ask for more time Extension or payment plan from whoever you owe | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Typical cost for $300 / 2 weeks | $45 ($15 per $100 is the common fee) | $0–$15 in 'tips', express fees, and subscription | $15–$75 (5–25% per month depending on state; you pay a full month even for 2 weeks) | Best here $0 — or one late fee ($5–$50) |
| Equivalent APR | ~390% (CFPB estimate for a typical two-week loan) | 0% if you tip nothing and wait; 100–300%+ with tips and instant fees | ~60–300% | Best here 0% |
| Credit check? | Usually no traditional check (may use alternative databases) | No — based on your bank account and paycheck history | No — the item is the only collateral | No |
| Builds credit? | No. Only shows up if it goes to collections. | No | No | No — but it protects your existing history |
| If you can't repay on time | Rollover with a new $45 fee, repeated bank debits and overdraft fees, then collections and possibly a lawsuit | Repayment is auto-debited on payday — can trigger overdraft. Access to future advances is cut off. No collections in most cases. | Best here You lose the item. Nothing else — no collections, no credit report, no debt. | Depends on the biller: another call, a late fee, or (for rent/utilities) escalation toward shutoff or eviction notices |
| Speed | Same day | Instant for a fee; 1–3 days free | Minutes | One phone call — but must happen before the due date |
| Legal in your state? | Banned or rate-capped in about 20 states + DC | Yes, everywhere | Yes, everywhere (rates capped by state) | Yes |
Pick this if…
Always try this first. It's free, and a 'yes' costs you nothing but a phone call.
The biller said no, it's a one-time gap, and next paycheck truly covers it. Tip $0, use the free transfer.
You own something you can live without and want zero risk of debt spiraling. The worst case is already known.
Honestly: almost never. If every other door is closed, borrow the minimum, ask about an extended payment plan up front, and do not roll it over.
Also check before borrowing anything: a paycheck advance from your employer, a small-dollar loan from a credit union (PALs are capped at 28% APR), and local emergency assistance through 211.
More decisions
Want answers personalized to your situation?
Tell us your #1 money goal and we'll tailor MoneyFAQ to you — free, takes 10 seconds.
Educational only — not legal, tax, or financial advice. Typical ranges are shown; your contract, lender, and state law set the exact rules. MoneyFAQ is not a lender.